Chantel Elasaad, 30 (Photo: Zara Katz)

Chantel Elasaad, 30, had been taking hormonal birth control pills from the time she was 14 years old to regulate her periods and subdue her intense cramps. With insurance, the pills cost her 35 cents a month in her homeland of Canada. In 2008, Elasaad moved to the United States on a temporary work visa and brought a supply of pills with her. When she ran out a few months later, she realized that she did not know how to get a new prescription.

“I was asking co-workers, friends, Googling things, like just trying to figure out, how can I get this? And no one really had a clear answer. I also didn’t have health insurance and didn’t have a primary doctor, which made the process even more difficult,” said Elasaad.

Without a primary care doctor, she didn’t know where to turn. The demanding and ever-changing hours at her job made getting an appointment at local low-cost clinics a challenge because, due to high demand, the clinics usually required making an appointment weeks in advance.

She had to stop taking the pill.

Elasaad’s story is just one version of the many obstacles women in the United States face in gaining access to hormonal birth control. That leads to frustrations for untold numbers of women. According to a 2010 report by the Centers for Disease Control on contraceptive use in the United States, 82 percent of women between 15 and 44 years of age who were sexually active had used the pill at some point between 2006 and 2008.

82 percent of women between 15 and 44 years of age who were sexually active had used the pill at some point between 2006 and 2008

Despite these numbers, many women still have trouble affording birth control and getting prescriptions. And in this election year, they also have to deal with the moral judgements of politicians and other public figures.

Forty years after hormonal birth control became widely available, it is back in the political limelight. In the past few months there has been an all-male Congressional hearing about the extent to which employer-based insurance should cover contraception. Catholic institutions have argued that being forced to provide birth control through insurers violates their religious freedom. Former presidential candidate Rick Santorum expressed his beliefs that contraception should not even be an option. Period.

Summer Starling, 30, a sexual health researcher and consultant, cannot believe that contraception issues are still a topic of political conversation.

“I think American women, particularly of our age, are a little confused about the debate,” she said. “I was on birth control in my teens and my 20s, and now I am in my 30s, and what is the debate here? We are moving backwards in our  discourse.”

According to Starling, there wasn’t really a debate about birth control in the 1980s and 1990s when it was covered by most insurance carriers. “People forget this,” she said. “They have sort of cultural amnesia about this.”

Summer Starling (Photo: Zara Katz)

Many women use hormonal birth control for health reasons beyond contraception, making the retrograde moral judgment even more frustrating.

Hormonal contraceptives can help with a variety of ailments. The pill can treat polycystic ovary syndrome, which can cause infertility and ovarian cysts. Hormonal birth control is used widely to temper heavy menstrual bleeding, severe cramps, premenstrual syndrome and acne.

Shauna Haynes, 30, is one such woman who needs hormonal birth control for more than just contraception. She has endometriosis, a condition in which cells that usually line the uterine walls grow in other parts of the body, causing excessive pain and irregular bleeding.

Shauna Haynes (Photo: Zara Katz)

Haynes is married and has insurance, but has faced problems getting her prescription filled.

She formerly went to her local Duane Reade drugstore for her birth control, until her insurance severed ties with that pharmacy. She tried transferring her prescription to Target, where she shops weekly, but her insurance required paperwork to make the switch. Haynes did the part of the paperwork that was her responsibility, but it wasn’t processed in time to keep up with her regimen.

So in the meantime, she went back to the first place she ever got birth control.

“I’m back to Planned Parenthood buying my pills until I get an appointment with my gynecologist, which has been really frustrating. I just feel like it really should not be that difficult,” said Haynes.

“It’s essential to my quality of life. I mean I’ve thought about this, how different my life would be if I didn’t have access to contraception.”

Some women turn to places like Planned Parenthood because they cannot afford primary health services or the cost of birth control. One of the most often-used services at Planned Parenthood is subsidized birth control. Both uninsured and insured women can get their birth control at a much lower price.

The nationwide health care provider also offers “comprehensive reproductive and complementary health care,” as written on its website. Uninsured women can go to Planned Parenthood instead of paying out of pocket to visit a doctor for treatment of urinary tract infections, for mammograms, and for annual tests such as pap smears.

Joanie Byrnes (Photo: Zara Katz)

Joanie Byrnes, 30, works in community outreach for a Brooklyn politician. Part of her job is to let constituents know about the services available to them.

“In this position a lot of women have come to me looking for services. I think a lot of people in general don’t know where to turn because healthcare is such a confusing thing for someone who’s not covered,” said Byrnes, who works in South Brooklyn.

Byrnes said she often informs women about organizations that give out mammograms for free, such as the American Italian Cancer Foundation, but also helps the community at large find out about other groups providing services, including the Visiting Nurse Service of New York, which gives out free flu shots.

Kendall McKenzie, 28 (Photo: Zara Katz)

Kendall McKenzie, 28, is a sex educator. From a young age, hormonal birth control helped treat her severe acne and irregular periods. She relates getting birth control to other necessities like toothbrushes or contact lenses.

“It’s essential to my quality of life,” said McKenzie. “I mean I’ve thought about this, how different my life would be if I didn’t have access to contraception. My relationships would be different. My level of happiness would be different. My outlook on life in general would be different.”



Photographs by Zara Katz


  1. Caitlin
    May 23, 2012

    Articles like this frustrate me. What about the women who use birth control because they are sexually active? This is the root of the problem – many people do not want women to own their sexuality and to be in control of their sexuality. Stories like this that ignore the real debate and simply focus on the other medical uses of the pill denigrate women who use it because they want to have sex and not have a baby. Let’s not fall into the political trap of dismissing the truth behind this debate.

  2. Caitlin
    May 23, 2012

    The only woman featured who is using it for sexual purposes is married and politically safe.

  3. Mary Jo Holland NP
    May 24, 2012

    There has always been a war on women. We had these battles in the 60’s and 70’s and here we are again. There are way to many men in politics and nobody cares about the separation of church and state anymore. They want to take away our birth control, our options for abortion, and Planned Parenthood. They don’t care about violence against women and jail us when we fight back. Getting birth control pills is difficult at times, but there are a lot of other serious things happening in women’s health today. We need to fight back! When a woman has to argue with her Gynecologist it’s time to find a new one!
    I liked the audio format. The stories were good but on the whole it was a little wishy-washy. Then again, I’m downright nasty when it comes to this subject.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.